Analyses / Europe, European Union, NATO
16 November 2026
What Is the Purpose of the European Union’s Common Foreign and Security Policy?
The Europeans have finally reached a decision: there will be seven envoys to represent them at the negotiating table in any potential talks on the war in Ukraine. Four Member States of the European Union (France, Germany, Italy and Poland), two representatives of the EU institutions (one from the Council, the other from the Commission), as well as the United Kingdom, will be involved in the peace talks, in accordance with terms and conditions to be communicated to them by Donald Trump and Vladimir Putin. Those who had hoped to see EU countries demonstrate their unity – and thus their strength – by appointing a single representative to deal with Trump and Putin have, once again, been left disappointed.
It is true that to imagine that the institutions and procedures painstakingly put in place by the EU to ensure its representation on the international stage could actually serve any purpose was utopian, if not naïve. How could anyone seriously believe that the Common Foreign and Security Policy (CFSP), which encompasses the Common Security and Defence Policy (CSDP), would enable Europeans to be represented at the negotiating table? How naïve, too, to think that the Treaties of Maastricht, Amsterdam, Nice and, finally, Lisbon – negotiated at the cost of many years of effort – were genuinely intended to serve any serious purpose one day.
Yet these treaties had gradually endowed the Union with institutions and functions designed to ensure its representation on the world stage. This is particularly true of the presidency of the European Council, currently held by António Costa, and the post of High Representative of the Union for Foreign Affairs and Security Policy, currently held by Kaja Kallas. They had also established a body, the Political and Security Committee (PSC), comprising twenty-seven ambassadors from the Member States, tasked with representing their governments specifically on foreign and security policy matters. They had also set up an administrative body, the European External Action Service (EEAS), as well as countless other bodies and structures, both within the EEAS and in other European institutions.
Yet, despite this procedural and administrative complexity, and despite all these efforts and compromises, the Member States had taken great care to exclude from their reforms the one measure that could truly have been a game-changer: that relating to the way decisions are taken, in order to overcome or, at the very least, circumvent the principle of unanimity. Undoubtedly, in this context, the idea of appointing a single negotiator, heading a multinational team tasked with supporting them, was nothing short of a pipe dream.
Paradoxically, during those four interminable years of war, the Europeans – and the EU in particular – had nevertheless managed to influence the course of the crisis, whilst maintaining a degree of unity, however precariously. Without their financial support, Ukraine would probably no longer exist today.
The problem is that the EU, a well-known economic power but an even more notorious political dwarf, seems incapable of going beyond financial aid, however important that may be in strategic terms, particularly when it takes the form of arms transfers. As soon as it comes to engaging on the military-diplomatic front, flexing its muscles, devising strategies, agreeing on common positions, negotiating, issuing threats and then finding compromises, the EU almost automatically steps back, leaving the field open to the Member States, their divisions and their illusions about national sovereignty.
The EU has always been a strategic sponsor without ever managing to become a genuine strategic actor. Once again, therefore, it will fund decisions which European capitals will have been under the illusion of making, but whose fate will, in reality, have been decided in Washington, Moscow and perhaps even Beijing.
This article has been translated from French into English using artificial intelligence.