![]() |
|
english version |
|
|
ACCUEIL > PUBLICATIONS > La revue internationale et stratégique N°66 La revue internationale et stratégique N°66 Summer 2007 SPECIAL ISSUE : Bleu gold, a new geopolitical stake ? sous la direction de Barah Mikaïl Pour lire le résumé d'un article, cliquez sur son titre. INSIGHTS The Anti-Terrorist Dynamic in Western Democracies: Rule of Law and State of Emergency / Colombe Camus
This article casts light on the devices used in the struggle against post-2001 terrorism in Western democracies. It aims to show what is induced in the long term by the extension of those methods and by their institutionalization, as far as liberal values and Rule of law are concerned. It points out that emergency measures have become commonplace, which tends to establish a new norm in politics, both within the states as well as within the international system. From this point of view, the article argues that there is no radical opposition between the United States and European democracies on this question, despite what is commonly said. Europe keeps putting forward different approaches, but it has nonetheless submitted to the anti-terrorist dynamic and to its potential negative consequences.
Being Young in Hizbullah / Bruno Lefort
The conflict between Israel and Hizbullah during the summer of 2006brought to light the vast support that the Lebanese people bring to the Shiite party. Indeed, not only is Hizbullah one of Lebanon’s greatest political parties but it is also its first-rate social actor. Students are one of its favourite targets. The study of the party’s presence in universities shows the complex construction process of collective and individual identities. The party guides the activity of its young militants in order to build networks of solidarity and to spread its values. However, its identity discourse changes according to places and circumstances. In the same way, students appropriate the party’s norms and modify them so that these norms fit with their personal environments.
European Identity and Political Community / Béligh Nabli
Defining a European identity based on shared values is essential, as it makes it possible to ensure the consistency of the European project, and to pursue and legitimate public policy. It can however be difficult to imagine such an identity, and this difficulty accounts for EU’s current political crisis. Yet the European identity actually emerges from social and economic values, and is embedded in the common cultural heritage and in the creation of a European juridical space. But the building of this supranational identity should not be carried out at the expense of national ones. The European Union thus remains faced with an existential debate: to achieve unity while respecting its diversity.
Peace Diplomacy Taking Shape in Africa / Jean-Luc Stalon
In the frame of the reinforcement of regional integration, an African peace diplomacy is currently being developed, in order to ensure peace keeping as well as conflict prevention and resolution in Africa. The Cold War context urged African political rulers to pursue a unilateral, and indeed competitive, peace diplomacy as they were prone to seek personal political prestige. Nowadays, however, the diverse incentives for mediation are better coordinated. The relationships between African regional organisations and international ones are progressively getting institutionalised. African regional organisations appear to be well-equipped to develop operational responses to conflicts. Nonetheless, their financial means are not capable of matching their ambitions.
SPECIAL FEATURE: BLUE GOLD, A NEW GEOPOLITICAL STAKE? Defusing the World Hydraulic Bomb / Barah Mikaïl THE POLITICS OF WATER: FROM COMPETITION TO COORDINATION Towards New Methods of Water Governance in Africa and Latin America / Philippe Hugon
The definition of the status of water is an important issue, the implications of which should not be disregarded. In theoretical debates, water can be seen as a public good, or, on the contrary, as an economic good. But those debates also look at the ethics of the issue, and they have a direct consequence for the way in which this resource is actually regulated. In Africa and Latin America, poor people often pay a price four times higher than others for water. To understand this paradox, this article analyses the role of both private operators and public actors, and takes into account criteria of efficiency and equity, as well as related political and social issues. In fragile states, the real question is not the privatisation of water, but the asymmetry of power relations, the respect of contracts and the institutional contexts.
Civil Society and New Patterns of Partnership for Access to Water in Developing Countries / Catherine Baron
Since the 1990s, water development policies have been in keeping with a bottom-up logic, in which NGOs are very much in the foreground. However, the “good governance” of water requires that the different levels of decision-making should be well-articulated. But discrepancies between discourses and practices make this difficult to achieve: the dogma of empowerment implies that the local dimension remains limited to the application of rules defined at a global level. This idealized approach is built on the injunction to the participation of civil society, but it does not take into account the political games at stake between the actors over the question of the access to water. On the contrary, a real participation requires that rules should be co-constructed, and it must be constantly negotiated as it cannot simply be ordered.
Blue Gold and Large Economic Areas: Redefining Inter-State Relations of Power? / Luc Descroix and Frédéric Lasserre
Recent institutional developments have reduced the growing tensions on water resources. In calling for international cooperation, they tend to substitute the principle of absolute territorial sovereignty for that of limited sovereignty. The case of the United States shows that the management of transboundary water is a hard task even for Northern countries, and illustrates the inequality of agreements with the South. Similarly, in West Africa, Central Asia and in the Mekong and Nile regions, institutional organisms have been created and represent a significant step towards the concerted management of water basins, as states are forced to cooperate. These new institutions, however, are confronted with problems related to the inadequacy of the Western model, the existence of unbalanced powers and the relinquishment of sovereignty.
WATER BETWEEN WAR AND PEACE Hydraulic Conflicts and Water Wars: An Attempt at Modelling / Frédéric Lasserre
In the current context of changing climatic conditions and growing food needs, the pressure on hydraulic resources is sharply increasing. Water has become a major political issue and both the control and sharing of water, are now potential sources of conflicts. These can be inter-state conflicts or low-intensity internal ones, but in both cases, hydraulic conflicts often only exacerbate existing tensions between states or communities, and they could entail real “water wars” if pushed to the extreme. The potential of conflict increases with the swiftness of the hydraulic rupture, which causes true water scarcity. However, societies appear more or less sensitive to this rupture, depending on their “capacity of social adaptation”.
Water and Military Strategy / Pascal Le Pautremat
Water has always been at the core of military strategies (bombing of shipping networks and water distribution sites, flooding of territories to disrupt the enemy’s progress, missions of maritime reconnaissance…). But since the end of the Second World War, the expansion of international trade has been accompanied by increasing maritime flows – flows that now represent 90% of total exchanges. This phenomenon makes it difficult to guarantee the security of those exchanges, which are challenged by terrorist networks or pirates, both of which are able to reach harbour areas and to launch attacks on the coast, even when far away from it. In reaction, great powers now acquire more and more refined maritime and amphibian means of actions.
Inter-states sharing of hydraulic resources often leads to conflicts, but in some situations, the management of water access can take place peacefully. As proof, a consensus has been reached between the United States and Canada on the question of fresh water sharing. The fact that Canada, though its is located upstream, did not intend by any means to impose draconian conditions to its meridian neighbour, paved the way for good relationships between both countries. The United States thus largely benefits from water resources coming from Canada, despite of its downstream position. The creation of a Commission for the arbitration and the resolution of disputes has also played a great role in the sound management of American-Canadian transboundary waters.
ON THE BOOKSHELVES Review Article Looking Back at the European Identity Issue / Robert Chaouad Book Reviews The Quarterly of International Relations Journals IRIS – Events and Publications |